Home | | Psychiatry | Ethics and Suicide

Chapter: Essentials of Psychiatry: Law, Ethics and Psychiatry

Ethics and Suicide

Much has been written about the ethics of suicide (Heyd and Bloch, 1991), and a number of philosophers, as well as phy-sicians, have argued that suicide may be rational under some circumstances.

Ethics and Suicide

 

Much has been written about the ethics of suicide (Heyd and Bloch, 1991), and a number of philosophers, as well as phy-sicians, have argued that suicide may be rational under some circumstances. Although US society no longer criminalizes at-tempted suicide, neither does it condone it. Thus, the strong current weight of ethical opinion, based on a commitment to the sanctity of life, is that usually psychiatrists ought to inter-vene to prevent or disrupt suicide attempts by patients. Further, according to this view, the psychiatrist’s duty to intervene may justify a breach of the ordinary obligation of confidentiality (see earlier discussion) and initiation of involuntary commit-ment and forced treatment proceedings because of the patient’s danger to self. Yet the obligation to respect the patient’s au-tonomy requires the psychiatrist to ask whether the intent to commit suicide in a particular case is sick and justifying – even mandating – intervention or whether it is a rational de-cision with which the physician has no ethical justification to interfere.

 

In a related vein, much debate has emerged in the past few years surrounding the ethical permissibility of physician-assisted suicide (Quill, 1991). Advocates for permissibility cite unbearable pain as a justification and submit that a regimen of procedural safeguards could adequately ensure against abuse (Quill, 1993). Among these safeguards would be the presence of a terminal or disabling condition from which there is no reasonable likelihood of recovery, the existence of an ongoing physician–patient rela-tionship, a patient capable of making decisions, and repeated and unequivocal requests by the patient for the physician’s assistance in hastening death.

Study Material, Lecturing Notes, Assignment, Reference, Wiki description explanation, brief detail
Essentials of Psychiatry: Law, Ethics and Psychiatry : Ethics and Suicide |


Privacy Policy, Terms and Conditions, DMCA Policy and Compliant

Copyright © 2018-2024 BrainKart.com; All Rights Reserved. Developed by Therithal info, Chennai.