Home | | Internet & World Wide Web HOW TO PROGRAM | | Internet Programming | | Web Programming | Legal Issues - e Business & e Commerce

Chapter: Internet & World Wide Web HOW TO PROGRAM - e-Business & e-Commerce

| Study Material, Lecturing Notes, Assignment, Reference, Wiki description explanation, brief detail |

Legal Issues - e Business & e Commerce

The Internet has posed significant challenges to the legal structure of the United States.

Legal Issues


The Internet has posed significant challenges to the legal structure of the United States. For example, file-sharing technology enables widespread copyright infringement, while Web-site personalization mechanisms threaten consumers’ privacy. In this section, we investi-gate the legal differences between our physical environment, which consists of temporal and geographic boundaries, and cyberspace, the realm of digital transmission not limited by geography. We also explore such issues as defamation, copyright and pornography as they relate to the Internet.


1. Privacy


Although an individual’s right to privacy is not explicitly guaranteed by the United States Constitution, protection from government intrusion is implicitly guaranteed by the First, Fourth, Ninth and Fourteenth Amendments.23 The Fourth Amendment provides U.S. citi-zens with the greatest assurance of privacy, protecting them from illegal search and seizure by the government:


The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrant shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the person or things to be seized.

Many Internet companies collect personal information from users as they navigate through a site. While privacy advocates argue that such efforts violate individuals’ privacy rights, online marketers and advertisers disagree, suggesting that the recording of user behavior and preferences helps online companies to better serve their customers. For example, if a user visits an online travel site and purchases a ticket from Boston to Phila-delphia, the travel site might record this transaction. In the future, when a ticket goes on sale for the same flight, the Web site can notify the user.


Online privacy also is impacting companies’ relationships with employees. Many businesses are implementing systems that regulate employee efficiency within workplaces. One of the newest surveillance technologies, keystroke cops, monitors employee activities on corporate and communications equipment. Keystroke software is loaded onto the hard drive of an employee’s computer, or it can be sent to an unsuspecting employee as an e-mail attachment. Once activated, the software registers each keystroke before it appears on the screen. In debates surrounding monitoring technology, a business’ right to regulate the use of company time and equipment is pitted against employee’s rights to privacy and freedom of speech. Situations can involve employees who neglect responsibilities to write personal e-mails, surf the Web or conduct online tirades against management in chat rooms.


2. Defamation

Defamation is the act of injuring another’s reputation, honor or good name through false written or oral communication. It is often difficult to win a defamation suit because the First Amendment strongly protects the freedom of anonymous speech (speech by an un-known person or a person whose identity has been withheld).


Defamation consists of slander and libel. Slander is spoken defamation, whereas libelous statements are written or spoken in a context in which they have longevity and per-vasiveness that exceed slander. For example, broadcast statements can be considered libelous, even though it is spoken.


To prove defamation, a plaintiff (the person bringing the argument to court) must meet five requirements: (1) The statement must have been published, spoken or broadcast; (2) There must be identification of the individual(s) through name or reasonable association; (3) The statement must, in fact, be defamatory; (4) There must be fault (for public persons, the statement must have been made in actual malice, or with the intention of causing harm; for private persons, the statement needs only to have been negligent, or published, spoken or broadcast when known to be false); and (5) There must be evidence of injury or actual loss.


3. Sexually Explicit Speech


Although pornography is protected under the First Amendment, obscenity is not, and par-ties can be held legally responsible for obscene statements. As determined in Miller v. Cal-ifornia (1973), the Miller Test identifies the criteria used to distinguish between obscenity and pornography. In the United States, pornography is protected by the First Amendment. To be determined obscene by the Miller Test, material must (1) Appeal to the prurient in-terest, according to contemporary community standards, and (2) When taken as a whole, lack serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value.

The Internet, with its lack of geographic boundaries, challenges the Miller Test. As we have stated, the Test is dependent on contemporary community standards. In cyberspace, communities exist independently from physical locations. Cyberspace complicates issues of jurisdiction by making it possible, for example, for a person in Tennessee, where the tol-erance for pornography is relatively low, to view a site that is hosted in California, where the tolerance is high.


The Internet possesses characteristics similar to those of broadcast media and print media, but problems arise in applying laws developed for those media to the Internet. Broadcasting is considered highly pervasive, and its content is strictly regulated. The Internet resembles broadcasting in its ability to reach a broad audience with little or no warning.28 By contrast, the regulation of print media focuses on limiting the audience, rather than the content, of the material. Defined as non-content-related means (an effort to control the audience rather than the material), print restrictions, for example, allow an adult to purchase and view pornographic material, but limit an adolescent’s ability to obtain that material. The Internet can mimic non-content related means by requiring users to provide identification before entering specific sites. Regulation of Web content could require the development of new legislation because of the Internet’s unique features.


4. Copyright and Patents


Copyright, according to the U.S. Copyright Office, is the protection given to the author of an original piece, including “literary, dramatic, musical, artistic and certain other intellec-tual works,” whether the work has been published or not. For example, copyright protection is provided for literature, music, sculpture and architecture. Copyright protects only the expression or form of an idea, not the idea itself.

Copyright protection provides incentive to the creators of original material by guaran-teeing them credit for their work for a given amount of time. Currently, copyright protec-tion is guaranteed for the life of the author plus 70 years. Concerns have been raised regarding the ability of traditional law to protect intellectual-property owners from online copyright infringement because of the ease with which material can be reproduced on the Internet. To complicate the issue further, digital copies are perfect duplicates of digital originals, making it difficult to differentiate authorized copies from pirated ones.


Patents, another form of intellectual property, grant the creator sole rights to a new dis-covery. Given the growth rate of the Internet, some argue that the 20-year duration of pat-ents discourages continuous software development and improvement.


In 1998, the federal regulations governing the distribution of patents increased the scope of patentable discoveries to include “methods of doing business.” To be granted a patent for a method of doing business, one must present an idea that is new and not obvious to a skilled person.

Study Material, Lecturing Notes, Assignment, Reference, Wiki description explanation, brief detail

Copyright © 2018-2020 BrainKart.com; All Rights Reserved. Developed by Therithal info, Chennai.