Home | | Medicine Study Notes | Ethical Issues in Dealing with Impaired or Incompetent Colleagues

Chapter: Medicine Study Notes : Ethics

Ethical Issues in Dealing with Impaired or Incompetent Colleagues

Collective responsibility as important as individual

Ethical Issues in Dealing with Impaired or Incompetent Colleagues

 

·        Summary:

o  Collective responsibility as important as individual

o  Maintenance of public trust vital

o  Better team work and error reporting will help

o  Self regulation: use it or loose it

·        Issues:

o  Trust of patients in doctors: patients in vulnerable position

o  Beneficence

o  Legal requirement to report impaired or incompetent doctor

o  Collective responsibility: to patient population as a whole

o  Uncertainty: may explain but not excuse failure to act 

o  Professional etiquette (often disguised as „clinical freedom‟) – not wanting to interfere in other‟s livelihoods 

o  Loyalty to the group: key to cooperation but should be overridden by maleficence

o  Pattern of error not a single mistake is indicative of incompetence 

·        Criteria for whistle-blowing:

o  Evidence of severe harm

o  Good chance of reducing harm

o  All other avenues explored

·        Ethical institutions

o  Encourage reporting of error (ie about safety not culpability)

o  Mechanisms for self/peer assessment

o  Internal complaints mechanisms (with protection)

o  Guard against malicious complaints

·        Culture within a group:

o  Less competent influencing each other

o  Professional isolation (big risk factor for incompetence)

·        Hard to pin down doctors because:

o  Lack of benchmarking (little medical practice has been validated)

o  Clinical freedom

o  „Half of all doctors are below average‟

o  The learning curve: period of necessary and acute incompetence 

·        Informed consent: what is it reasonable for patients to know about their doctors (eg individual success rates) vs. doctors right to privacy

 

Study Material, Lecturing Notes, Assignment, Reference, Wiki description explanation, brief detail
Medicine Study Notes : Ethics : Ethical Issues in Dealing with Impaired or Incompetent Colleagues |


Privacy Policy, Terms and Conditions, DMCA Policy and Compliant

Copyright © 2018-2024 BrainKart.com; All Rights Reserved. Developed by Therithal info, Chennai.