THE ABSENCE OF CONTINGENCY
The importance of contingency is
also evident in another way—in an organism’s reac-tion when there’s no
contingency at all. To explore this idea, let’s imagine two different
procedures. In both, the animal hears 40 presentations of a tone and receives
20 elec-tric shocks. In the first procedure, these stimuli are presented
randomly—and so there’s no contingency, no relationship, between hearing the
tone and receiving a shock. In the second procedure, the stimuli are arranged
so that half of the tones are followed by shock and half are not, and shocks
are never presented without a tone preceding them. In this setting, hearing the
tone signals a 50% chance that a shock is about to arrive; in the absence of
the tone, the chance of shock is zero.
Animals react very differently to
these two procedures. In the first, the tone conveys no information—shock is
just as likely with a tone as without. Not surprisingly, the tone in this
situation does not become a fearful stimulus. Indeed, after just a few
pre-sentations of the tone—so that the novelty of this stimulus wears off—the
animal’s behavior doesn’t change at all when the tone is sounded. In the second
procedure, in contrast, the tone is informative, indicating that a shock quite
likely is about to arrive. It’s no wonder that in this case the animal soon
shows a fear response whenever the tone is presented.
These two procedures also differ
in another way. The first procedure—with its ran-dom arrangement of tones and
shocks—is far more aversive to animals. This is clear, for example, if we
monitor the animals’ bodily state (e.g., their heart rates) during both
procedures. The comparison tells us that the animals are more stressed in the
noncon-tingent procedure. We can also, in effect, “ask” animals which of these
procedures they find worse. We do this using a lab setup in which the animal
can enter either of two chambers, one governed by the random procedure we’ve
described and one governed by the contingent procedure. When given these
options, animals reliably choose the second procedure.
What’s going on here? In the
second procedure, there is a clear “danger signal” for the animal (the tone),
and this signal reliably produces fear. But this setup also provides a clear
“safety signal”—namely, the absence
of the tone. When the tone isn’t sounded, the animal knows no shock is coming
and it can relax. In the first (noncontingent) pro-cedure, in contrast, there’s
never a danger signal, nothing to indicate when a shock is coming, and therefore
no specific trigger for fear. But, in this setting, there’s also no indication
when the animal is safe. As a result, in this procedure the animal is
constantly afraid and constantly on guard.
Results like these highlight the
importance of contingency—the relations among stimuli that allow us to
anticipate upcoming events. When there is some contingency (i.e., one event
allows predictions about another event), animals learn this; and it seems to be
crucial for classical conditioning. But when there’s no contingency, ani-mals
learn this, too—and learn that their environment is unpredictable. These points
are crucial for, say, dogs in a conditioning experiment, but they’re no less
important for humans. For example, think about why terrorist activities are so
frightening: Terrorists hope to convey the message that they can strike you
anytime, anywhere, so that you’re never safe. It’s this absence of contingency
that makes terrorist threats so scary. Similarly—but on a more personal
level—think about the distinction between fear and anxiety. According to some
theorists, fear is a state triggered by a specific situation or object;
anxiety, on the other hand, is chronic, has no object, and occurs in many
situations. Some authors suggest that such unfocused anxiety is partly caused
by unpredictability—that is, by an absence of safety signals (B. Schwartz et
al., 2005; Seligman, 1975).
Related Topics
Privacy Policy, Terms and Conditions, DMCA Policy and Compliant
Copyright © 2018-2024 BrainKart.com; All Rights Reserved. Developed by Therithal info, Chennai.